The 1902 Montreal Experimental Machine Cancellations
In 1902, the Canada post office had become disenchanted with the Bickerdike machines then
in use in a number of offices. They were about to be replaced by International machines,
which were first tested in Toronto in early February. The Bickerdikes continued in use in
Hamilton until October and in Ottawa and Montreal until November. In the intervening
period other machines were tested in the Montreal post office. Very little is known about
these machines, but there were two main types of dater hubs used. The webmaster has for
some time kept a record of uses of these experimental machines, which you will find below.
Further reports (with scans if possible) would be much appreciated, and can be made to
the webmaster.
|
The first to appear was a rimless dater, as shown in the first figure at right. We have confirmed use from January 6 to February 15. It is
the appearance of this dater hub that has led some to speculate that this machine was
manufactured by Geary, as the hub resembles one used by Geary in Bradford PA around that
time. This conclusion should be taken with some skepticism however. Reference [7] in particular considered
all known American machine makers of that period and settled on Geary as the likely supplier. Geary did in
fact possess an 1897 Canadian patent
(CA 55409)
for a feeding mechanism for a mail marking machine.
If this did not in fact offer patent protection for a Geary machine, it is perhaps unlikely that a machine
would be tested in Montreal under those circumstances. Nor
is there evidence that Geary spent any time at all in Montreal; given the many changes in the
postMARks throughout 1902, the maker would certainly have had to spend considerable time there.
The contract with the International Postal Supply Co. was
drafted in April of 1902 (with the International testing having taken place in Toronto) and it seems rather odd that
another machine would be tested for so long in Montreal before and after this event. It should be noted that the rimless
dater in fact resembles a rimless dater used in Boston and Philadelphia in American Postal Machines Co. machines. It may be that
these experimental machines were simply surplus Imperial machines (close relatives of the American machines) held in the Montreal
post office. There is also some indication that a postal employee A.E. Morin may have experimented on machines during this period. He
did in fact hold a patent (CA 67543) for
a feeding mechanism for a postal cancelling machine.
|
Hub X2 |
|
A second dater hub replaced the rimless dater starting in mid February. It may not be immediately clear whether or not this
was used in the same machine. However, the record of uses seems compelling in this regard. This second hub resembles that used in the International machines, in that
it has the year at the bottom, but it also has some differences. The diameter seems to match that of the
International hubs, but all International hubs used by the Canada Post Office had provincial (or country) designation, apart of course from
the Type A dater used in an International machine in Toronto in 1902.
A number of different obliterators consisting of rough straight lines were used with this dater hub as
time went on, and none resemble those used in International machines.
|
Hub X1 |
Below, we give a time-line of the experimental machine use. The EKU and LKU dates given should be understood
to be those that we have been able to confirm. In some cases, earlier or later dates have been reported to other
sources. Such instances are noted below. By clicking on each item, you can reveal a table of confirmed
sightings. The type designations are those established in [6].
|
X2(a) (EKU: JAN 6, LKU: JAN 28)
| JAN 6 | 1?-O | Bank letter to Wingham, front only | | | JAN 8 | ??-O | 1¢ CPR postal card to Switzerland | | | JAN 8 | 17-O | 1¢ CPR postal card to city | | | JAN 8 | 17-O | 1¢ CPR postal card to Victoria BC | | | JAN 13 | 19-O | 1¢ CPR card to Toronto (Chateau Frontenac) | | | JAN ? | ??-O | unreadable scan in [7]; possibly JAN 17 | | | JAN 22 | 19-O | 1¢ postal card to Bass River NS | | | JAN 23 | 13-O | 1¢ postal card to Montreal | | | JAN 23 | 17-S | 2¢ letter card to city | | | JAN 24 | 19-O | 2¢ letter, W. James Wurtele corner | | | JAN 24 | 19-O | 2¢ letter to Charlottetown, torn | | | JAN 28 | 17-O | unconfirmed report in [6] | | | JAN 28 | 19-O | 5¢ letter to Germany; Geo. D. Ross corner | | | JAN 28 | 22-O | 1¢ postal card to Durocher St. | |
|
X2(b) (EKU: FEB 5, LKU: FEB 13)
| FEB 4 | 13-O | unconfirmed report in [11] and [6] | | | FEB 5 | 18-O | letter to Halifax, Harrower Co. corner | | | FEB 5 | 19-O | 2¢ letter to Halifax, Thos. C. Doyle corner | | | FEB 5 | 20-O | 2¢ letter to Lower Stewiacke, J.C. Wilson corner | | | FEB 6 | 19-O | postal card to Harrow | | | FEB 7 | 18-O | 1¢ CPR postal card to Norwich date uncertain? (see CPR report date) | | | FEB 10 | 19-O | 2¢ letter to Arichat, McLea corner | | | FEB 12 | 20-O | 1¢ Grand Trunk postal card to Alabama | | | FEB 13 | 13-O | 1¢ CPR postal card to Montreal | | | FEB 15 | ? | unconfirmed report in [10] | |
|
X2(rec) (EKU: JAN 12, LKU: FEB 15) hub used alone as a receiving or transit MARk
| JAN 12 | 10-O | receiver | | | JAN 18 | 19-O | 2¢ letter from Ottawa, addressed to Edward Rawlings | | | JAN 25 | 11-O | receiver on back of cover | | | JAN 27 | o-9 | receiver on back of cover | | | JAN 27 | 22-O | receiver on Greek postcard | | | JAN 29 | 9-O | receiver | | | JAN 30 | 22-O | receiver | | | FEB 3 | 17-O | receiver | | | FEB 4 | 4-O | receiver | | | FEB 4 | 11-O | receiver on Allan Line postcard | | | FEB 4 | 13-O | receiver on back of cover | | | FEB 4 | 21-O | 3¢ letter from Quebec, Merchants Bank | | | FEB 4 | 24-O | receiver on back of cover | | | FEB 5 | 8--O | receiver on back of cover | | | FEB 5 | 9-O | receiver on back of cover | | | FEB 5 | 22-O | receiver on back of cover | | | FEB 7 | 5-O | 3¢ letter from Winnipeg, Merchants Bank | | | FEB 8 | 10-O | receiver | | | FEB 14 | 20-O | 1¢ postal card from Peterboro | | | FEB 15 | 19-O | receiver on front of US postal card from Boston | | | FEB 15 | 21-O | on back of letter card | | | FEB 17 | ? | unconfirmed report in [11] | |
|
X1 (EKU: FEB 18, LKU: MAY 1)
| FEB 18 | 19-O | 2¢ letter to Halifax, Geo. D. Ross corner | | | FEB 20 | 19-O | 2¢ letter to Halifax, Standard Shirt corner | | | FEB 21 | 19-O | 2¢ letter, possibly partial | | | FEB 24 | 19-O | 2¢ letter to Ottawa, Chronicle corner | | | FEB 25 | 19-O | 1¢ postal card to NewMARket | | | FEB ?? | 17-O | 5¢ letter to Vienna, Bank of Montreal corner | | | MAR 7 | 18-O | 2¢ CPR statement [Banff] to Southsea | | | MAR 7 | 18-O | 1¢ (Hotel Vancouver) CPR postal card to Norwich | | | MAR 7 | 19-O | 2¢ letter to city, Royal Paper Mills corner | | | MAR 8 | 19-O | 2¢ drop letter, Herald Publishing Co. corner | | | MAR 12 | 19-O | 2¢ letter to Halifax, Gilmour Bros. corner | | | MAR 12 | 19-O | 2¢ drop letter | | | MAR 14 | 18-O | 1¢ postal card to Montreal | | | MAR 14 | 19-O | 1¢ private postcard to Upper Stewiacke | | | MAR 18 | 19-O | 2¢ letter to city, Molsons Bank corner | | | MAR 19 | 20-O | 2¢ letter to Halifax, Rhode Island corner | | | MAR 20 | 11-O | receiver on back of cover | | | MAR 27 | 19-O | 2¢ letter to Halifax, A. Ramsay corner | | | MAR 29 | 18-O | 2¢ letter to Cowansville, Molson Bank corner | | | MAR 31 | 20-O | 1¢ GTR statement [Parry Sound] to Chicago; ex Payne | | | APL 3 | 11-O | 1¢ CPR card (Place Viger Hotel) to UK | | | APL 4 | 19-O | 2¢ letter to Moncton, Hudon corner | | | APL 7 | 18-O | 1¢ postal card to Bell Telephone, Wales, Ont. | | | APL 9 | 18-O | 2¢ letter to Hamilton | | | APL 10 | 19-O | 2¢ letter to Orono, Ont., Guardian corner | | | APL 11 | 19-O | 2¢ letter to Halifax, Dorken Bros. corner | | | APL 16 | 19-O | 1¢ postal card to city | | | APL-17 | 19-O | 2¢ letter to North Williamsburg, Hodgson Bros. corner | | | APL 18 | 19-O | 2¢ letter to Halifax, Dorken Bros. corner | | | APL 18 | 20-O | 2¢ drop letter, Montreal Street Railway Co. | | | APL 19 | 13-O | 2¢ letter to Ottawa, National Trust corner | | | APL 22 | 18-O | 2¢ letter (front) to N.E. MARgaree C.B., W.D. Stroud corner | | | APL 25 | 18-O | 1¢ postal card to NewMARket | | | APL 25 | 20-O | 2¢ letter to Halifax, Rhode Island corner | | | APL 28 | 20-O | corner of envelope | | | APL 29 | 20-O | CPR envelope | | | APL 30 | 20-O | 2¢ letter to C.B., Sherwin-Williams corner (front) | | | MAY 1 | 19-O | 2¢ letter to Halifax, Consumers Cordage corner | |
|
X1 undated (3rd class)
| (no date) | | 1¢ third class letter to Toronto (front) | |
|
X3 (EKU: MAY 1)
| MAY 1 | 15-O | 1¢ postal card; ex Sessions | | | MAY 1 | 19-O | 2¢ letter, Charles E. Frosst corner | |
|
X5(a) (similar to X5 but with 9 bars) (EKU: MAY 2)
| MAY 2 | 19-O | 2¢ letter to Halifax, Lamplough & McNAUGhton corner | | | MAY 2 | 19-O | 2¢ letter, A. Ramsay & Son corner, possibly partial | |
|
X4 (6 bars from 50mm to 65mm in length) (EKU: MAY 3, LKU: JUN 2)
| MAY 3 | 13-O | 1¢ (Mt. Stephen) CPR postal card to UK | | | MAY 3 | 14-O | 1¢ (Hot Springs) CPR postal card to Cambridge MA | | | MAY 3 | 16-O | 1¢ (Mt. Stephen) CPR postal card to UK | | | MAY 3 | 16-O | 1¢ (Glacier House) CPR postal card to Gibraltar | | | MAY 3 | 14-O | 2¢ CPR postcard to Cambridge MA | | | MAY 8 | O--19 | 2¢ letter to North East MARgaree CB, Empire Tobacco corner | | | MAY 14 | O--19 | 2¢ letter to Halifax, Pilkington corner | | | MAY 14 | 20-O | 1¢ postal card to Windsor NS | | | MAY 16 | ?19 | hand-drawn illustration in [3] | | | MAY 21 | O--19 | 2¢ letter to London, Consumers Cordage corner | | | MAY 22 | O--19 | hand-drawn illustration in [2] | | | MAY 22 | 20-O | 2¢ letter to Halifax, Lamplough corner | | | MAY 23 | O--19 | uprated postal card to France | | | MAY 23 | 20-O | unconfirmed report in [6] | | | MAY 26 | O--20 | 2¢ letter to Halifax, Dorken Bros. corner | | | MAY 27 | O--19 | 1¢ postal card to Winnipeg | | | MAY 27 | O--19 | 1¢ postal card (2x4?) | | | MAY 29 | O--19 | 2¢ letter to Prescott, Seybold & Sons corner | | | MAY 29 | O--19 | 2¢ letter to London, B.&S.H. Thompson corner | | | MAY 29 | O--19 | 2¢ letter to North Williamsburg, Hodgson Bros. corner | | | MAY 29 | O--19 | 2¢ letter to Guysboro NS, 17 Victoria Square corner | | | MAY 30 | O--19 | 2¢ letter, William Buck Stove Co. corner | | | MAY 30 | O--19 | 2¢ letter, W.W. Ogilvie Milling Co. corner | | | JUN 2 | O--19 | 2¢ letter to Cobourg, Hermann H. Wolff corner | | | JUN 2 | O--19 | 2¢ letter to Kemptville, B. Levin & Co. corner (front) | |
|
X4(a) (possible variant of X4, bars set slightly lower relative to hub than X4) (EKU: JUN 3, LKU: JUN 6)
| JUN 3 | 17-O | 2 ¢ stationery, National Trust corner, possible partial | | | JUN 3 | --19 | 2¢ letter to Wingham (front) | | | JUN 3 | O--19 | 2¢ letter to Halifax, W.W. Ogilvie corner | | | JUN 3 | O--19 | 2¢ letter to Halifax, Dorken Bros. corner | | | JUN 4 | O--19 | 2¢ letter to London | | | JUN 4 | O--19 | 2¢ letter, Molson Bank corner, possibly partial | | | JUN 4 | O--19 | 2¢ letter to Halifax, Pilkington corner | | | JUN 5 | O-19 | 2¢ letter to Halifax, J.W. Windsor corner | | | JUN 6 | O--19 | 2¢ letter to Halifax, Dominion Wire corner | |
|
X5 (EKU: JUN 9, LKU: AUG 14)
| JUN 9 | O--19 | 2¢ letter to London, Dominion Wire corner | | | JUN 10 | 7-O | 1¢ private post card to Brussels | | | JUN 10 | O--19 | 2¢ letter to Kemptville, Lewis Bros. corner (front) | | | JUN 10 | O--19 | 2¢ letter to London, H.R. Ives corner | | | JUN 11 | 19-O | 2¢ letter to Cobourg, Hermann H. Wolfe corner | | | JUN 11 | 19-O | 2¢ letter to Guysboro NS, 17 Victoria Square corner | | | JUN 11 | 19-O | 1¢ private post card, Friedman Bros. corner | | | JUN 12 | 19-O | 2¢ letter to Stanstead | | | JUN 12 | 19-O | 2¢ letter to Camden East, John L. Cassidy corner | | | JUN 12 | 19-O | 2¢ letter to Halifax | | | JUN 13 | 18-O | 2¢ letter to Wingham, Bank of Montreal corner | | | JUN 17 | 19-O | Allan Line postcard to Ireland | | | JUN 17 | 19-O | 2¢ letter to London, Canada Paint corner | | | JUN 18 | 18-O | scan in [7] | | | JUN 18 | 19-O | 2¢ letter to Barachois CB, W.D. Stround corner | | | JUN 20 | 19-O | 2¢ letter to Halifax, Pilkington Brothers corner | | | JUN 24 | 19-O | 2¢ letter to London, Rhode Island barrel corner | | | JUN 25 | 19-O | 2¢ (Blaiklock Bros.) letter to Nashua NH | | | JUN 30 | 19-O | 1¢ postal card to city | | | JUL 2 | 10-O | 1¢ CPR card (Hot Springs Hotel) to Batiscan Stn. | | | JUL 2 | 15-O | 1¢ CPR statement [Hot Springs Hotel, Banff] to Kirksley | | | JUL 2 | 15-O | 1¢ (Place Viger) CPR postal card to Gibraltar | | | JUL 2 | 19-O | 2¢ letter to Halifax, Canada Paint corner | | | JUL 3 | 18-O | 1¢ CPR statement [Mt. Stephen House] to Derby | | | JUL 3 | 19-O | 2¢ letter to New York, Orient Stamp Co. | | | JUL 3 | 19-O | 2¢ letter to Port Hope | | | JUL 3 | 20-O | 2¢ letter to London, Consumers Cordage corner | | | JUL 4 | 19-O | 2¢ letter to Amherstburg, Empire Manufacturing corner | | | JUL 4 | 20-O | 2¢ letter to Halifax, Lamplough corner | | | JUL 8 | 18-O | 1¢ CPR postal card to France, JUNe 28th date on obverse | | | JUL 8 | 19-O | cut corner of 2¢ letter | | | JUL 8 | 19-O | 2¢ letter to Galt | | | JUL 9 | 19-O | 2¢ letter to Halifax, Consumer Cordage corner | | | JUL 9 | 19-O | 2¢ letter to Halifax, Ogilvie corner | | | JUL 10 | 18-O | 2¢ letter to Kemptville, Bank of Montreal corner | | | JUL 10 | 18-O | 2¢ letter to Halifax, Thompson corner | | | JUL 10 | 19-O | 2¢ letter to London, A. Ramsay corner | | | JUL 10 | 19-O | 2¢ letter, Walter Grose corner | | | JUL 15 | 19-O | 1¢ postal card to Bass River NS | | | JUL 17 | 19-O | 1¢ postal card to Winnipeg | | | JUL 31 | 18-O | 2¢ letter to Amherstburg, Standard Life corner | | | AUG 1 | 19-O | 1¢ postal card to Bass River NS | | | AUG 5 | 19-O | 2¢ letter to Kemptville, P.D. Dods corner | | | AUG 7 | 19-O | 2¢ letter to Manchester, Geo. D. Ross corner | | | AUG 8 | 19-O | 2¢ letter to Mahone Bay, James Linton corner | | | AUG 13 | 18-O | 2¢ letter to Ottawa, Ontario Bank corner, possibly partial | | | AUG 13 | 19-O | 10¢ letter to Germany, Geo. D. Ross corner | | | AUG 14 | 19-O | 2¢ letter to Matrone Bay, Percival Bros. corner | | | AUG 16 | ? | unconfirmed report in [6] | |
|
X1(rec) (EKU: FEB 17, LKU: AUG 14) hub used alone as a receiving or transit MARk
| FEB 17 | 9-O | on US postcard | | | FEB 18 | 24-O | on US postcard | | | FEB 20 | 8-O | on US postcard | | | FEB 20 | 22-O | on back of envelope | | | FEB 21 | 10-O | | | | FEB 24 | 19-O | 1¢ postal card | | | MAR 5 | 22-O | receiver on US cover | | | MAR 8 | 12-O | letter from Rochester NY | | | MAR 9 | 9-O | receiver on back of cover | | | MAR 10 | 14-O | 2¢ drop letter | | | MAR 12 | 24 O | receiver on back of cover | | | MAR 13 | 21-O | 2¢ letter to G.A. Holland, Mrs. Dennie corner | | | MAR 14 | 22-O | receiver on back of cover | | | MAR 22 | 20-O | 2¢ drop letter, Empire Typewriter corner | | | MAR 26 | 8-O | 2¢ drop letter to C.A. Holland | | | APL 8 | 12-O | receiver on postcard | | | APL 11 | 21-O | receiver on back of cover | | | APL 21 | 20-O | receiver on back of cover | | | MAY 3 | 10-O | 2¢ letter from Upper Stewiacke | | | JUN 16 | 20-O | 2¢ letter from Morrisburg, St. Lawrence Hall corner | | | JUN 20 | 9-O | receiver | | | JUN 20 | 20-O | | | | JUL 11 | 9-O | 5¢ letter to DenMARk (transit MARking) | | | AUG 4 | 20-O | receiver | | | AUG 5 | O--8 | receiver | | | AUG 5 | 17-O | US letter to Montreal | | | AUG 6 | 9-O | on picture postcard | | | AUG 14 | 20-O | receiver | |
|
Bibliography
- History of Rapid Cancelling Machines, part 2
Edward Goodale, Popular Stamps, MARch 1943, pp. 16-17.
- The Machine Age (part 4)
Dr. C.W. Hollingworth and Dr. M.W. Carstairs, MAPLe Leaves No. 127, p. 183, October 1970.
- Machinations (Part 2)
David F. Sessions, MAPLe Leaves Vol. 16, No. 1, p. 6, April 1976.
- Geary Machine Cancels
John W. Koontz, Machine Cancel Forum #47, pp. 401-8, MARch 1978.
- The Rapid Cancelling Machine Experimental Dies
David F. Sessions, PHSC Journal 18, p. 11, AUGust 1980.
- The Early Rapid Cancelling Machines of Canada
David F. Sessions, Can. Phil. Soc. GB and Unitrade Press, Toronto, 1982.
- The 1902 MARkings of Montreal -- Identified at last
Reg Morris, Machine Cancel Forum #103, pp. 1507-22, November 1982.
- International Postal Supply Company Machine Cancellations: Comments and Speculation on
their use During 1902 and 1903
Geoff Newman, PHSC Journal 33, p. 4, MARch 1983.
- Mystery Montreal MARkings Unmasked
David F. Sessions, MAPLe Leaves Vol. 19, No. 6, (Whole No. 198, JUNe 1984), pp. 160-63.
- The Rimless American Machine Cancel, Philadelphia 1890
Norman Shachat, Pennsylvania Postal Historian, pp. 6-7, November 1989.
- The Bickerdike Flags - A Revision and Suggested Pricing Structure
David F. Sessions, The Flag Pole, Vol. 5, No. 4, pp. 2-12, MARch 1992.
- The Classic Flags - A SumMARy
David F. Sessions, The Flag Pole, Vol. 7, No. 3, pp. 3-8, September 1993.
- Anthology of Machine Postal MARkings Vol. 7: An In-Depth Look at James Geary Machine Cancels
Robert J. Payne, Machine Cancel Society, 2002.
|
|